Brookhaven Homes for Sale

2009/03/28     / / / /

If you want to be almost guaranteed of seeing someone walking a Golden or Labrador Retriever, then drive through Brookhaven. Some consider it part of Buckhead some think of it as a separate community. Regardless, it has some architecturally significant and truly elegant Atlanta homes. The historic Capital City Club anchors the neighborhood with its golf course. It’s why the homes in Brookhaven Atlanta are in high demand.

It’s one of those neighborhoods whose boundaries seem to mysteriously grow larger as neighboring communities try to piggyback on its cache. This has caused some people to refer to the original Brookhaven as “Historic Brookhaven” to differentiate it from the newer “Brookhaven”, with an eastern boundary that seems to end somewhere near Stone Mountain.  Brookhaven real estate has always been, and continues to be, very desirable.

Here are the Brookhaven homes for sale in Buckhead, Atlanta that are currently on the market:

Atlanta Homes For Sale in Brookhaven

Showing properties 1 - 34 of 34. See more Brookhaven.
(all data current as of 5/23/2013)

  1. 3 beds, 2 full baths
    Home size: 1,450 sq ft
    Year built: 1964
    Parking spots: 2
    Square foot source: Builder
    Broker reciprocity icon
  2. 4 beds, 3 full, 1 part baths
    Year built: 1939
    Parking spots: 2
    Square foot source: Not Available
    Broker reciprocity icon
  3. 5 beds, 5 full, 3 part baths
    Year built: 1992
    Parking spots: 3
    Square foot source: Not Available
    Broker reciprocity icon
  4. 4 beds, 4 full, 1 part baths
    Home size: 4,148 sq ft
    Year built: 1949
    Parking spots: 2
    Square foot source: Tax Record
    Broker reciprocity icon
  5. 4 beds, 3 full, 1 part baths
    Home size: 2,292 sq ft
    Year built: 2002
    Parking spots: 2
    Square foot source: Tax Record
    Broker reciprocity icon
  6. 5 beds, 4 full baths
    Home size: 2,990 sq ft
    Year built: 2013
    Parking spots: 2
    Square foot source: Builder
    Broker reciprocity icon
  7. 4 beds, 3 full, 2 part baths
    Home size: 2,910 sq ft
    Year built: 1945
    Parking spots: 2
    Square foot source: Tax Record
    Broker reciprocity icon
  8. 5 beds, 5 full, 2 part baths
    Home size: 6,942 sq ft
    Year built: 1994
    Parking spots: 2
    Square foot source: Appraisal
    Broker reciprocity icon
  9. 4 beds, 4 full, 1 part baths
    Year built: 1936
    Parking spots: 3
    Square foot source: Not Available
    Broker reciprocity icon
  10. 4 beds, 2 full, 1 part baths
    Home size: 2,572 sq ft
    Year built: 1962
    Parking spots: 1
    Square foot source: Appraisal
    Broker reciprocity icon
  11. 4 beds, 4 full, 1 part baths
    Home size: 4,900 sq ft
    Year built: 1996
    Parking spots: 2
    Square foot source: Tax Record
    Broker reciprocity icon
  12. 5 beds, 4 full, 1 part baths
    Home size: 4,513 sq ft
    Year built: 2000
    Parking spots: 2
    Square foot source: Appraisal
    Broker reciprocity icon
  13. 5 beds, 5 full baths
    Home size: 4,147 sq ft
    Year built: 1999
    Parking spots: 2
    Square foot source: Tax Record
    Broker reciprocity icon
  14. 4 beds, 3 full, 1 part baths
    Home size: 3,595 sq ft
    Year built: 1933
    Parking spots: 2
    Square foot source: Builder
    Broker reciprocity icon
  15. 4 beds, 3 full, 1 part baths
    Home size: 3,284 sq ft
    Year built: 1947
    Parking spots: 2
    Square foot source: Tax Record
    Broker reciprocity icon
  16. 5 beds, 3 full, 1 part baths
    Home size: 3,208 sq ft
    Year built: 2006
    Parking spots: 2
    Square foot source: Builder
    Broker reciprocity icon
  17. 6 beds, 6 full, 2 part baths
    Home size: 4,416 sq ft
    Year built: 1920
    Parking spots: 3
    Square foot source: Tax Record
    Broker reciprocity icon
  18. 7 beds, 6 full, 1 part baths
    Home size: 5,837 sq ft
    Year built: 2002
    Parking spots: 3
    Square foot source: Tax Record
    Broker reciprocity icon
  19. 6 beds, 6 full, 1 part baths
    Home size: 5,334 sq ft
    Year built: 1992
    Parking spots: 2
    Square foot source: Tax Record
    Broker reciprocity icon
  20. 4 beds, 4 full baths
    Year built: 2000
    Parking spots: 2
    Square foot source: Not Available
    Broker reciprocity icon
  21. 4 beds, 3 full, 1 part baths
    Home size: 3,308 sq ft
    Year built: 1985
    Parking spots: 3
    Square foot source: Tax Record
    Broker reciprocity icon
  22. 4 beds, 3 full baths
    Home size: 2,174 sq ft
    Year built: 1959
    Parking spots: 2
    Square foot source: Tax Record
    Broker reciprocity icon
  23. 4 beds, 3 full baths
    Home size: 3,955 sq ft
    Year built: 2000
    Parking spots: 2
    Square foot source: Appraisal
    Broker reciprocity icon
  24. 4 beds, 4 full, 1 part baths
    Home size: 4,735 sq ft
    Year built: 1935
    Square foot source: Tax Record
    Broker reciprocity icon
  25. 4 beds, 4 full, 2 part baths
    Home size: 3,787 sq ft
    Year built: 1985
    Parking spots: 2
    Square foot source: Tax Record
    Broker reciprocity icon
  26. 5 beds, 3 full baths
    Home size: 2,053 sq ft
    Year built: 1945
    Parking spots: 2
    Square foot source: Tax Record
    Broker reciprocity icon
  27. 4 beds, 5 full, 1 part baths
    Home size: 6,650 sq ft
    Year built: 2007
    Square foot source: Appraisal
    Broker reciprocity icon
  28. 4 beds, 3 full, 1 part baths
    Home size: 3,000 sq ft
    Year built: 2012
    Parking spots: 2
    Square foot source: Builder
    Broker reciprocity icon
  29. 3 beds, 2 full, 1 part baths
    Home size: 2,340 sq ft
    Year built: 2001
    Parking spots: 2
    Square foot source: Tax Record
    Broker reciprocity icon
  30. 6 beds, 6 full, 2 part baths
    Year built: 1993
    Parking spots: 2
    Square foot source: Not Available
    Broker reciprocity icon
  31. 6 beds, 5 full, 1 part baths
    Home size: 6,400 sq ft
    Year built: 2007
    Parking spots: 3
    Square foot source: Builder
    Broker reciprocity icon
  32. 4 beds, 3 full, 1 part baths
    Home size: 3,039 sq ft
    Year built: 2012
    Parking spots: 2
    Square foot source: Builder
    Broker reciprocity icon
  33. 4 beds, 4 full baths
    Home size: 3,395 sq ft
    Year built: 1960
    Parking spots: 2
    Square foot source: Tax Record
    Broker reciprocity icon
  34. 5 beds, 4 full, 2 part baths
    Home size: 4,835 sq ft
    Year built: 2001
    Parking spots: 3
    Square foot source: Tax Record
    Broker reciprocity icon

Listing information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Read full disclaimer.

Brookhaven is often mentioned in the Atlanta McMansion battle. It originally had a mixture of premium luxury homes and some beautiful cottages with loads of curb appeal. Recently, many of the historic cottages and bungalows have been torn-down and replaced with beautiful, larger homes. The residents of Brookhaven are sharply divided over private property rights versus maintaining the diversity and original character of the neighborhood. Personally, I think it’s incorrect to characterize the newer homes in Brookhaven as McMansions. Most of the new homes are very tasteful and are not the big, cheap houses, filling every square inch of the lot, that seem to define Atlanta McMansions.

Here are some other comments about Brookhaven from Buckhead.net:

On the northern edge of Buckhead, Brookhaven developed as Atlanta’s first country club neighborhood. It begins just north of the intersection of Peachtree Road and Peachtree-Dunwoody Road. Its boundaries generally are Peachtree Road on the east, Peachtree-Dunwoody on the west and south and Windsor Parkway on the north.

Now sometimes referred to as West Brookhaven, it is an enclave of large, elegant Tudor, Colonial, Georgian and English cottage homes in a lush landscape of broad, winding streets, densely wooded hollows and gently rolling hills with the Capital City Country Club as its heart.

In what was once Creek Indian land, the area’s first white settler was Harris Goodwin, a South Carolinian who homesteaded a tract on both sides of what is now Peachtree Road in the early 1830s. Harris Goodwin later brought his father, Solomon, to the area. The Goodwin home and a small graveyard in which they are buried survive at 3931 Peachtree Road near the intersection of Dresden Drive.

The original log cabin on the Echota Indian Trail was expanded in the 1830s and 1840s into the present home. In 1864, it was a landmark for Federal troops closing in on Atlanta during the Civil War. Goodwin descendants still own the property. The home is the oldest extant house in DeKalb County. It is open to the public from 1 p.m. to 4 p.m. on the third Sunday of every month, and a family member is usually there to serve as a guide.

In 1910, 150 acres on the west side of Peachtree was bought by the Mechanical and Manufacturers Club for a golf club to be called Brookhaven. The course, which encircles a large lake and is surrounded by woods, was laid out by course architect Herbert Barker. The original clubhouse was replaced in the 1920s by the present French Provincial structure of mellow stone. Shortly after opening in 1911, the club became part of the downtown Capital City Club and became known as the Capital City Country Club.

In the 1980s, the area was placed on the National Register of Historic Places as the “first planned golf club community in Georgia.”

On November 6, 2012, Brookhaven was formally voted on to become a town. As of January 21, 2013 the officials were still planning the structure of the city. So, for the time being, I’ll have to start referring to it as Brookhaven Atlanta GA.

Erika Eaton

Erika is a top-performing REALTOR with Atlanta Fine Homes Sotheby's International Realty. Erika provides unique insight into Atlanta / Buckhead living and real estate through her blog, which is updated regularly. You can also connect with her on Google+

  /  

5 COMMENTS

Things That Inspire - 2009/04/22 -

I think that Historic Brookhaven is the most beautiful part of Atlanta, primarily because it has a consistency that is often lacking in Buckhead (although, of course, there are some incredibly beautiful areas of Buckhead). Very interesting post!

LEAVE A COMMENT
You filled this out wrong.
You filled this out wrong.
You filled this out wrong.
You filled this out wrong.

FMLS LogoListings identified with the FMLS IDX logo come from FMLS, are held by brokerage firms other than the owner of this website and the listing brokerage is identified in any listing details. Information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed. © 2013 First Multiple Listing Service, Inc.
Data last updated: 5/22/13 11:59 PM PDT.

Walk Score provided by walkscore.com.

For issues regarding this website and/or listing search engine, please contact Diverse Solutions.

This IDX solution is (c) Diverse Solutions 2013.